Grain-Free Pet Food Frenzy

Grain-Free Pet Food Frenzy – the Evidence Seems…Grainy

Recently, NBC did a report that grain-free foods are causing a type of potentially deadly heart disease called dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs. The veterinarian they interviewed specifically said dogs need a grain-based dog food. Sadly, people are now being scared off all grain-free foods. We caution that there have been a lot of sweeping generalizations by the media, by people on social media and by veterinarians regarding this issue, that seem perverse to create hysteria when in actuality, the facts are few.

You can easily Google this issue now and find advice such as, “Change your dog’s diet to one made by a well-known reputable company and that contains standard ingredients (e.g., chicken, beef, rice, corn, wheat).” Or better yet, “If you’re feeding your dog a boutique, grain-free, or exotic ingredient diet, stop!”

The characterization of “fad based/boutique” grain-free foods is unnecessarily inflammatory. Please consider that major pet food companies, who most trust are “backed by science” or are a “reputable company” (including but not limited to Science Diet- owned by Colgate-Palmolive, Champion, Mars, and Purina) either make grain-free diets themselves, or they’ve bought out smaller competing manufacturers who do (Large parent corporations shroud these acquisitions from the public eye by maintaining their original branding). Terms of “science-based diets” vs. “fad based/boutique diets” are an over simplistic, and dare we say, ignorant way to draw a line in the sand of, “good” vs. “bad”. Grain-free diets have been around for a lot longer than one should consider, “a fad” and it has only been recently that issues have come to light. So what has happened? Without details, who can tell? And honestly, we may never figure it out.

What is Dilated Cardiomyopathy?

Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a disease of a dog’s heart muscle that results in an enlarged heart. As the heart and its chambers dilate, it becomes more difficult heart to pump blood efficiently.  The heart valves may leak, leading to a buildup of fluid in the chest and abdomen.  DCM often results in congestive heart failure.  Symptoms of DCM include tiring easily, shortness of breath, and coughing.

History of the Report By NBC

Over the last year or so, some astute veterinary cardiologists began to take note that unique breeds of dogs, not typically known to develop dilated cardiomyopathy were, well, developing dilated cardiomyopathy. They also noted that they were fed grain-free diets. They surmised there was a connection between the two and the cardiologists reported their concerns to the FDA. This led the FDA to release a warning in July of this year that grain-free dog foods which rely heavily on potatoes, legumes, and exotic proteins, may have a possible connection to the development of dilated cardiomyopathy. Vegan and homemade diets were also reportedly involved. Again, this caught the FDA’s attention because some of the dogs were not the breeds typically known to develop DCM due to taurine deficiency or genetic factors. These atypical dog breeds included Labrador Retrievers, Whippets, Miniature Schnauzers, one Shih Tzu, one Bulldog, and an unspecified number of mixed-breed dogs.

Specifically, the FDA stated that diets in cases reported to the FDA frequently list potatoes or multiple legumes such as peas, lentils, other “pulses” (seeds of legumes), and their protein, starch and fiber derivatives early in the ingredient list, indicating that they are main ingredients. The FDA has further clarified that “foods containing multiple pulses that appear near the top of the product’s ingredient list have appeared more frequently in the reports we have received thus far.” Early reports from the veterinary cardiology community indicated that the dogs consistently ate these foods as their primary source of nutrition for time periods ranging from months to years. High levels of legumes or potatoes appear to be more common in diets labeled as “grain-free,” but it is not yet known how these ingredients are linked to cases of DCM. (Source)

Scientific evidence and statistics are based on the premise that, correlation does not equal causation, and there are likely to be many other factors at play. It is simply not good science to observe something and make conclusions. There are dozens of grain-free dog foods on the market, and without knowing which brands are involved, it’s impossible to know for certain what ingredients, manufacturing processes or other factors may be at fault.

The association between diet and DCM is likely far more complicated than simply blaming the problem on one or two ingredients. It seems clear that the interplay between genetics and one or several of ingredients, and perhaps the food’s overall content of methionine, cysteine, l-carnitine, and taurine due to processing or inadequate supplementation, is at the root of DCM in these cases. But at this point, no one–FDA or otherwise–has any idea which factors are actually problematic, or in what amounts or combinations.

For example, ingredients are listed by weight on the pet food label; using multiple legumes, potatoes, or fractions thereof (a practice referred to as “splitting”) allows a company to include far more plant protein than meat protein, while allowing the named meat to remain at the top of the ingredient panel. So, it may not be potatoes or legumes that are the problem; rather, it may be an overwhelming amount of potatoes or legumes compared to meat.  

Also, the FDA failed to indicate whether the associated foods were dry, canned, or both. It’s probably safe to assume that most or all were dry foods, since that is what the vast majority of dogs are fed in the U.S. But it is worth noting that, in the case of cats, canned foods need supplemental taurine at a much higher level than dry foods, because cats’ gut bacteria interact differently with those food forms. So, there may be.  

It seems odd that this problem should occur now, even though potatoes have been used in dog food—particularly “hypoallergenic” formulas—from the large “science-based” pet food companies—for decades. For example, Hill’s Science Diet d/d lists potatoes, potato starch, [venison, salmon, or duck], and potato protein as its first four ingredients. One would think such a diet would be particularly dangerous, except that Hill’s also adds taurine to these foods.  

So, is this warning of pets requiring grains justified, based on science? Where’s the proof?

History

Prior to WWII, more than 90% of commercial pet food came in cans, and contained mostly, if not only, meat. However, as you can imagine, tin metal was rationed and diverted from pet food companies to the military and over-processed, shelf-stable kibble was the solution. At the end of the war, 85% of pet food was dry kibble. Kibble at that time still contained a large amount of meat, likely preventing taurine deficiencies from occurring (we’ll talk about taurine more soon).  

The process of creating dry kibble is called extrusion. During the 1950’s, the primary machinery for producing kibble, called an extruder, was introduced. In order for an extruder to create the correct consistency of ‘dough’, a minimum amount of starch is needed. This started the trend of increasing the quantity of cereal grains, such as corn, into dry pet foods. Concurrently, meat processors were becoming more proficient at removing meat from livestock carcasses. This allowed pet food manufacturers to substitute higher quality meat products for other leftover animal tissues or “by-products.” Over time, the result was a high-grain, low-meat or worse, low-quality-meat dry food, for which the profit margin is, conveniently, much higher than for canned food. Regardless, at the time, pet owners were delighted. Dry pet food was less messy and stinky and more convenient. 

Fast forward to the late 1970s. Cat owners and their vets were noting a large number of cats going blind or dying of congestive heart failure due to a condition called dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). (Source)  Researchers at UC Davis noted that many of those cats were eating the same food (Hill’s Science Diet). In the mid-1980s, they published the results of their research showing that taurine deficiency was the issue. It was found that taurine is a dietary requirement for cat health, as cats cannot make it themselves. Pet food manufacturers scrambled to supplement taurine in their feline diets. Since then, DCM (dilated cardiomyopathy) dramatically decreased in cats eating commercial, “balanced” cat food supplemented with taurine. (Please note, that cats can develop DCM unrelated to taurine, and a genetic form exists in some breeds, but that is beyond the scope of this article).

Let’s Consider Taurine for a Minute

Taurine is an amino acid that can be produced by many mammals in an organ that sits near the stomach called the pancreas. Even though many mammals can make taurine, they require amino acid precursors such as methionine and cysteine in order to do so. Basically, the manufacturing chain of taurine is as follows, animals use an essential amino acid called methionine to make cysteine and then taurine is made from cysteine. Taurine is nutritionally found in muscle meat and organs like the heart, kidney, and liver and in seafood. It is also abundant in the brain and eye. It is an essential component of bile acids, used to break down fats from food.

Taurine is imperative for health. It is required for proper muscle function, most notably, heart muscle. Taurine is important for brain and eye health. It acts as a potent antioxidant and anti-inflammatory agent and is essential for immune system function. Taurine has been shown to improve periodontal disease in humans. It also helps regulate blood pressure and is an extremely important cellular protector. So, a diet deficient in taurine causes eye problems and (eventually) irreversible blindness, hair loss, tooth decay and heart disease. Heart disease, specifically, dilated cardiomyopathy secondary to low levels of taurine in the diet is generally reversible by adding taurine to the diet. Thus, taurine is now a requirement of the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) in cats, but AAFCO nutrient profiles do not specify a required level of taurine in dogs

Wait, what is AAFCO?

As stated earlier, AAFCO stands for the Association of American Feed Control Officials.  Some pet owners, pet stores, and even some veterinarians believe that AAFCO is responsible for approving pet foods but in fact, this isn’t true.

AAFCO is a voluntary organization, whose advisors and committee members include representatives from major feed manufacturers and ingredient suppliers such as Nestle Purina, Hills Pet Nutrition, Nutro Products and Cargill Animal Nutrition.  Despite this, AAFCO claims that its function is to protect the consumer.  It has no power to regulate, test, or approve pet foods. (Source) It’s not a government agency like the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) or the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), so AAFCO does not have any regulatory authority. Instead, AAFCO has established a series of nutritional standards for ‘complete and balanced’ pet foods. The nutrient profiles set forth by AAFCO list minimum and maximum levels of intake for protein, fat, vitamin and mineral content of foods.

AAFCO’s standards are adopted by most states and these nutritional standards are the ones most pet and livestock feed manufacturers must adhere.  With that said, AAFCO does not perform any analytical testing of foods and it is the pet food company's responsibility to formulate their products according to the appropriate AAFCO standard.  However, “AAFCO does not endorse any laboratories” listed on their site, that “conduct nutritional and/or toxicological analyses of animal feeds (including pet foods and treats).”  (Source)

Any dog food manufacturer that wants to make the claim that their food is ‘nutritionally complete’ or is ‘complete and balanced’ must meet AAFCO’s nutritional requirements, feeding trial requirements (generally a 6 month test to see if an animal survives eating a particular food), or produce a food similar to one which has met these requirements.

When one thinks about a feeding trial, one envisions lots of pets tested, lab coats, years of testing, …a big deal!  In actuality, here is how it happens.  A trial for adult maintenance food for example only needs 8 animals.  The food being tested must keep 6 out of 8 dogs/cats alive and generally healthy for 6 months.  They cannot lose more than 15% of their initial body weight or without significant changes to basic blood values.  To state the obvious, most nutritional deficiencies or excesses will not be apparent within a brief 6-month trial, as they tend to take much longer to develop (Source). 

How on earth, does an AAFCO feeding trial lasting a short 6 months, requiring more or less, that an animal survives, confirm the safety and reliability of a pet food?

The FDA (Food and Drug Administration) and a state’s feed control official are responsible for regulating pet foods. 

Now that we got that out of the way…back to taurine 

The availability of taurine is affected depending on how the food is prepared, with raw diets typically retaining the most taurine, and baking or boiling resulting in the greatest taurine loss (Source). Even worse, if a water-based cooking method is used (i.e. rendering cooks the meats into a huge liquid soup, which is then dehydrated to make kibble), most of the taurine contained in tissues will be dissolved into water. Also, bacteria destroy taurine, so the longer the animal protein used in the food has been dead, the lower the taurine content. Again, this may be particularly important when rendered products are used to make pet food. 

Taurine, Cysteine, Methionine, L-carnitine, and Dogs

Dogs make their own taurine primarily from an amino acid called cysteine but can also make it from another amino acid building block called methionine. It was thought that, because they could produce it themselves, dogs didn’t need taurine supplemented to their diet, like their cat counterparts.

It has been known since 1997, that a link exists between taurine deficiency and DCM in dogs. Some dogs can’t make enough taurine for their taurine needs. DCM is a somewhat common form of heart disease of large and giant breed dogs. It is now known that larger breed dogs produce taurine at a slower rate than smaller breed dogs, increasing the risk for a deficiency. Genetics might also play a significant role, with certain breeds and family lines being predisposed to developing DCM. For example, certain spaniels, retrievers (specifically Golden Retrievers), and Newfoundlands are known to develop the same taurine-dependent form of DCM that made all those cats sick in the 1970s and 1980s. Diet is likely a factor in about 20-30% of dogs who develop DCM; supplementing taurine may reverse the disease. Age seems to also decrease the rate of taurine synthesis in dogs.

However, it may not be a specific taurine deficiency in the food that is a contributing factor in DCM. Some research suggests it may be insufficient cysteine that limits the dog’s ability to produce taurine. Remember that dogs make cysteine from methionine and taurine from cysteine. Any weak link in the chain of methionine, cysteine or taurine could be problematic. Methionine and methione + cysteine have minimum level requirements in dog food according to current AAFCO standards, but again, no taurine requirements. (Source)

L-carnitine, another amino acid found primarily in meat, may also play a role in the development of DCM in a small percentage of dogs. L-carnitine becomes unavailable in pet food through processing and is generally not added back due to its high cost. (Source)

During the 1997 studies, most of the dogs with DCM were eating lamb and rice dog foods. It is worthwhile to note that lamb, venison, and rabbit have a relatively low level of building block amino acids compared to beef, chicken, and other poultry. Another study found that dogs eating foods containing beet pulp had lower blood taurine levels.

Possible reasons for low blood taurine levels in dogs fed an otherwise “complete and balanced food” that have been suggested but not fully investigated include: 

  • Differences in protein digestibility and bioavailability may limit available precursors
  • Interference with reabsorption of taurine-containing bile acids in the gut so that more taurine is excreted
  • Interaction of food and/or food form (canned vs. dry) with gut bacteria - Disruption of the microbiome (gut bacteria population) alters taurine bioavailability in cats through the action of gut bacteria; perhaps this is true for certain dogs as well.
  • Type of processing that limits taurine bioavailability
  • Perhaps there is some intrinsic factor in legumes and potatoes that is acting as an “anti-nutrient” and binding or otherwise interfering with taurine metabolism.
  • Something is happening during processing that is causing taurine in these foods to become unavailable. (For example, we know that heat processing diminishes taurine from fish by about 30%.)
  • Affected dogs may have altered pancreatic function, such as subclinical pancreatitis, that prevents nutrient absorption and/or adequate taurine synthesis.

These possibilities should be investigated further. However, with that said, an association of taurine or one of its precursors or perhaps a completely different essential protein element or something else entirely may be at play here. Again, not all animals have tested with low taurine levels.

What can you do for now?

At this time, the FDA is not recommending a diet change, as their investigation is in the very early stages (i.e. perhaps too soon for media coverage) with little concrete information. They have found DCM in dogs eating all kinds of foods, from those with a simple ingredient list to very complex foods.

It is also important to note that not all dogs with DCM—and not even all dogs who also had very low blood levels of taurine—responded to taurine supplementation. This implies that it isn’t necessarily taurine itself that’s the problem; but as noted, it certainly could be lack of methionine and/or cysteine. Conversely, many of the sick dogs had perfectly normal blood taurine levels.

It seems AAFCO will likely need to revisit their Nutrient Profiles and either (1) increase the minimum for methionine, (2) increase the minimum for methionine-cystine, and/or (3) add a notation that cysteine and taurine are at least conditionally essential amino acids for dogs. Taurine minimums for cat food may also need re-examining, as cats have also been affected. (4) or perhaps something entirely different and not on anyone’s radar.

How Can You Protect Your Pet?

Those of us who are passionate about animal nutrition have been having a painful awakening for some time now about just how nutrient-deficient many dogs and cats are today. There is a difference between thriving and surviving. This is potentially just another example that animals need much higher levels of bioavailable amino acids from a variety of sources than most are consuming. Make sure your dog’s food contains mostly meat and not half a dozen vegetables or fractions (potato starch, pea fiber, etc.) that add up to the largest proportion of the food.

The problem with grain-free formulas likely isn’t the lack of grains, as the veterinarian on NBC reported. It’s potentially the high level of starchy carbohydrates (the splitting practices described earlier), coupled with the extreme high-heat processing methods used to produce these diets.

If you have a breed or breed mix known to be susceptible to DCM (e.g., Golden Retriever, Doberman Pinscher, Cocker Spaniel, Boxer, Great Dane, Scottish Deerhound, Irish Wolfhound, Saint Bernard, Afghan Hound, Dalmatian, Portuguese Water dog, Old English Sheepdog, Newfoundland), especially if you’ve been feeding grain-free kibble, or if for some other reason you’re concerned about your dog’s heart health, we recommend scheduling an appointment to discuss further by calling (312) 757-7809.

Also, continue to be an advocate for your pet by keeping yourself up to date. The FDA has released a “Questions and Answers” post for consumers. They revealed that their initial report involved 30 dogs and 7 cats. They now have 150 confirmed reports of affected dogs and an unknown number that are being examined. With growing public awareness, there are undoubtedly hundreds of reports pending, but not all will be confirmed as taurine-deficiency DCM. It is possible for a dog to have DCM with completely normal taurine levels, and some dogs with low taurine levels will not develop DCM. Check back frequently on the FDA website for updates. 

There is also a FaceBook group called: Taurine-Deficient Dilated Cardiomyopathy, that has helpful information including files of diets fed and associated taurine levels.  Please note that infromation is confidential to members of that group and cannot be shared. 

If you are concerned and would like to have your pet’s taurine level checked, please call us at (312) 757-7809. We submit our tests to UC Davis. Normally their turnaround time is 48 hours, but due to current high demand, turn around time may be 1 week.

Most importantly, of the tens or perhaps hundreds of thousands of dogs eating “boutique” and grain-free foods, only a very small percentage are linked to the problem

Personally, we would like to see “the science” and what exactly all of this means before hitting the panic button as there may be many ‘spinning plates’ in motion regarding this issue. Most of what has been released by the media, seems so far, to be premature conjecture based on reckless theories and biases.

We will continue to monitor the situation and keep you updated! 

Blog Category: